Skip to main content

tv   The Ed Show  MSNBC  March 15, 2011 10:00pm-11:00pm EDT

10:00 pm
survey debris fields out at sea and the military also says it has provided the japanese government with two fire trucks. no u.s. military personnel were lost in the quake or the tsunami in japan. all u.s. military personnel based in that country have been accounted for. that said, several sailors were given potassium iodide tablets today as a thyroid cancer preventative after they returned from flying humanitarian missions. radiation detection equipment found evidence of low levels of radiation on either the sailors or their helicopters as well as a number of additional helicopter crews later in the day. our navy says the humanitarian missions nevertheless will continue. now it's time for "the ed show." thanks for being with us tonight. good evening, americans. welcome to "the ed show" tonight from new york. our lead story tonight a live report coming up from japan in just a moment. the unfolding disaster there and coming up the battle ground that must not be ignored right here in the united states. if you thought governor scott walker of wisconsin was bad, wait until you see what governor john kasich of ohio is doing
10:01 pm
when it comes to picking up where walker left off. with a budget that would cut funds to schools. here's a new one for you. and even children's hospitals. how nice of them. the second front of the war on the middle class well under way. plus the very latest from wisconsin. it's wednesday morning in japan and the brave souls of that country are trying to prevent the world's worst serious nuclear accident since chernobyl from becoming even a bigger disaster. at this hour the numbers are staggering. the number of confirmed dead, well over 3,000, but at least 10,000 are feared missing. almost 7,000 confirmed missing. but tens of thousands of believed to be unaccounted for. the numbers are all over the map and it's just hard to gather the magnitude of this. nearly a half million are now homeless. 850,000 homes are still without electricity as temperatures outside drop to near freezing. the country continues to face an
10:02 pm
invisible threat -- radiation. levels spiked following near meltdown at japan's fukushima nuclear plant. japanese officials tell the iaea that radioactivity was being released, quote, directly into the atmosphere after enduring so much already survivors are unsure if they are safe. >> nuclear power is the most frightening thing even more than a tsunami. the government, the ruling party, the administrators, nobody tells us the citizens what is really happening. >> frustration growing no doubt. the crisis is now officially considered a level six emergency surpassing the disaster at three mile island, a level five. four explosions have occurred at the plant since friday. just hours ago, another fire broke out at the number four reactor. officials say the blaze erupted because the initial fire from yesterday had not been fully put out. they are now considering spraying water and acid into the
10:03 pm
reactors to prevent further radiation. all but 50 workers at the plant have been ordered to leave. two workers have been reported missing following an explosion tuesday. 70,000 people have been evacuated from homes within a 12 mile radius of the nuke plant. those living within a 20 mile radius have been ordered to stay in their homes but many are not taking chances and are questioning the government's information. >> this is the main road from fukushima into tokyo. it's the evening rush hour and the traffic should be going in that direction. instead, thousands of people are trying to get out of the town and into the main city and this is one of the very few shops on the way. it's extremely busy. >> and inside the shelves are empty. many have searched for food for hours. they are desperate. in tokyo some 150 miles south of the plant radiation levels have
10:04 pm
spiked. experts say it is not an immediate threat to human health but the long-term effects are unknown. we are just beginning to understand the long-term economic effects of this. analysts say the economic loss is likely to be well over $170 billion for the most devastated areas. but as japanese stocks appear to be rebounding from losses yesterday reuters is reporting the disaster has forced many firms to suspend production. global companies are facing disruption after vital infrastructure was damaged or destroyed. here in the united states subaru has suspended overtime at its plant in lafayette, indiana. and toyota is suspending overtime in saturday production at all of its north american plants. back in japan, residents of the most devastated areas are still trying to grapple with what happened. this was the town of utsushi just five days ago. here it is today after tsunami
10:05 pm
waters receded fire fueled by kerosene in cooking stoves simply burned the entire town and burned it to the ground. it has left nothing. >> i have no idea what's going to happen, he told us. and then looking off into the distance he said the whole town has gone. the town next door is gone. it's as if i'm living in a dream. >> joining me now from tokyo is nbc news correspondent and msnbc anchor chris jansing. chris, thanks for your time tonight. i know it's been long duty over there and must be very gut wrenching for you as well to see the strife the people are experiencing there. what is your impression of the japanese people? how are they holding up through all of this now that we're in day five? >> reporter: it's heart breaking and i'm sure that's not surprising for you to hear. i have compared it, being here, to the feeling i had in new york city post 9/11. it has been such a devastating
10:06 pm
blow to the psyche of this nation. if you've ever spent any time here you know this is a very proud country, an island where almost 99% of the people are ethnic japanese. if you read about this country, some people will say, well, it's kind of like they divide the world into two -- japanese and nonjapanese. and the people here are very proud. it is the world's third largest economy. it is i think per capita the most successful, the richest asian nation. and they are generally a very united, very proud country. and this is truly tearing them apart. it is heart breaking to watch, ed. it really is. >> and they are down to the basics -- food, water, searching. searching for loved ones and looking for the basics right now. and we hear a number of sound bites in our news coverage that the people aren't trusting the government. do you hear that a lot on the
10:07 pm
ground? >> reporter: you know, you do. and i will say that in the people that i have talked to both japanese and experts here, you're not going to hear people say we think the government is lying. what you will hear them say is that there is a sense of unease. are they being told the whole story? and maybe even more frightening, do they really know the whole story? and i think a good example is what you talked about in your setup, what's going on at reactor four. first the official announcement was there's a fire. but it's been put out. and then it was that there is a second fire and then, well, we now think this second fire was because the first fire never really was put out. it's those kind of series of reports that really have people uncomfortable. and then you have international companies who are withdrawing. folks even from here in tokyo 150 miles away, you have the french government telling their people to leave tokyo. you have the austrian government
10:08 pm
moving its embassy 200 miles away from here to osaka. so those are the kinds of things that certainly lead to questions and i think that the truth of the matter is given the unprecedented nature of this, the fact that we are at a level six and some experts would argue potentially moving toward a chernobyl-like number seven, are there really answers? do they have the answers, ed? and, clearly, so far it's been no. >> it must be. and i'm just speculating here, and you help us out with this, it must be really hard to get good, confirmed information on the ground, because everything seems so chaotic and so much is in disarray and there's been such tremendous devastation. speak to that, chris, that it is hard to get a grip on what exactly is happening at the hour, isn't it? >> yeah, and let me put it to
10:09 pm
you in the most human terms that i possibly can, because i spent an hour or more standing outside of the u.s. embassy and i wanted to talk to americans as they were coming out. three families came out, ed, all of them considering leaving the country. all of them had lived here for many years. they have homes here. they have jobs here. i talked to a couple. they were there with their 3-year-old and 5-month-old twins. they were getting those twins passports because they were, indeed, thinking about moving back to the states. and when i said, how will you make that decision? on what will you base that? and first of all, he expressed his unease with the type of information that was out there, the reliability of that information, but what he said that struck home that i think everyone can relate to is he said, my fear is that by the time it's clear to me that i need to get my family out of here, then it's too late. by the time it's absolutely
10:10 pm
obvious that even tokyo is not a safe place for me and my wife and my three children, i've waited too long. so those are the kinds of issues that people here are grappling with and i don't want to overstate it, particularly here in tokyo, where even though the levels of radiation are -- have been detected at ten times normal levels. you know, this is not anywhere near a life threatening situation but there is definitely a fear that it could become that and an unease about how will we know when that point has been reached, ed? >> chris jansing reporting for us tonight from tokyo and a reminder to our listeners that chris will be anchoring from tokyo in the next hour right here on msnbc. chris, thanks so much for joining us tonight on "the ed show." here now to discuss the unfolding nuclear crisis is the president of the institute for energy and environmental research. welcome to the program tonight.
10:11 pm
where do we stand at this hour? how are things the way you see it? >> well, i think some things are not deteriorating and others new tragedies and difficulties seem to be unfolding every day. so the initial reactor where the trouble started, number one, they had that hydrogen explosion. it blew the roof off. and as i've been saying, the place to worry about, number one, and also number three, is the central pools which store the highly radioactive waste which are just as vulnerable to meltdown and fires and dispersal of radioactivity as the reactor, in some ways more vulnerable because they're more exposed. and the other thing that happened today is the pool in reactor four had a fire and hydrogen explosion and poked a hole in the reactor building and that seems to be venting radioactivity. some of the outside
10:12 pm
radioactivity levels at one point on tuesday morning here eastern were quite high, about 4 million times natural background levels. workers would get an annual dose in a few minutes. the workers who are working there are working in a very, very difficult environment. it's very difficult to say how this is going to evolve. i don't believe this is at the level of chernobyl yet. but i would agree that it certainly has the potential to go there. >> take us through this process. officials are considering spraying water and acid into the reactors to prevent further radiation. this is somewhat unchartered waters for everybody on the globe right now dealing with this over a five-day period. take us through that process. is that something that would be successful do you think? >> well, this is an -- this is rewriting the playbook for accidents in a way, or the
10:13 pm
textbook for accidents. because four reactors at the same time. yes, normally you do try to inject boric acid and mixed in water and the boron is to control and prevent a chain reaction from occurring and causing further structural damage and heat. the water is to keep the spent fuel or in the reactors the fuel cooled because the radioactivity generates an enormous amount of heat. it's like a pressure cooker. and in a pressure cooker, if you don't vent it, it will blow up on you. so the valves have to work and in this case the heat is inside the pressure cooker so you can't switch it off. so you've got to keep pouring more water and venting the heat and the steam and the steam is radioactive and so that's why the radioactivity levels keep going up and down but when you get a pulse like a fire, then the outside radioactivity levels can get pretty high and they've
10:14 pm
been measured somewhat elevated as far away as tokyo. >> you can only imagine the pressure that these human beings are under trying to control this. >> oh, yes. >> i mean, it must be just unbelievable working in this environment just frantically trying to do the right thing and it's hard to know exactly where you are, isn't it? >> yes. i think that in some ways, you know, these folks are not only heroic and self-sacrificing. some things they do seem to be keeping under control like reactor one and maybe the reactor three, the reactor, itself, the pressure cooker. but i have been worried from the beginning about the spent fuel pools. the big swimming pools near the roof of the reactor where all the highly radioactive waste is stored. now, the amount of waste in one, two, and three is significant but not huge. i don't know how much waste there is in number four. and i suspect more because it
10:15 pm
caught fire. now, it's very difficult to put water in a damaged pool and that i think is the situation they may be fighting for some element of surmise on my part but since the explosions took place near the top of the reactor and certainly in reactor four it seems to be associated with the pool, it would be quite hard, it's like pouring water into a bucket that's leaking. >> yeah. thank you so much for joining us tonight here on "the ed show." for the rest of the hour, this is what's on the table tonight. from the beginning, the images from japan have been pouring in unlike any other moment in histo history in our time. the story and the video that you haven't seen. we'll show it to you tonight. could the latest crisis there happen here? with nuclear plants in this country that are situated in earthquake zones? and the despicable talk that must be addressed when the likes
10:16 pm
of beck and limbaugh actually mock victims. that's in the takedown. plus the very latest from ohio and wisconsin. we've not forgotten the middle class in this country. stay with us. we're right back. . it helps the largest of companies seize opportunity like the smallest of startups. it's the network-- the intelligent, secure cisco network that lets your employees, partners, suppliers and customers innovate and share so you can unleash the power of your most valuable asset: your people. we're america's natural gas. and here's what we did today in homes all across america: we created the electricity that powered the alarm clocks and brewed the coffee. we heated the bathwater and gave kelly a cleaner ride to school. cooked the cube steaks and steamed the veggies. entertained dad, and mom, and a neighbor or two. kept watch on the house when they slept.
10:17 pm
and tomorrow we could do even more. we're cleaner, domestic, abundant and ready now. we're america's natural gas. the smarter power today. learn more at anga.us. be sure to check out our new blog. there you'll find links to twitter and facebook. join up with us. coming up despite the nuclear crisis in japan the push for more nuclear power in the united states is not slowing down. what you need to know about nuclear safety in america, next. you're watching "the ed show" on msnbc. [ male announcer ] a chicken coop: the unlikely birthplace of a fundamental idea. it's where ethel percy andrus found a retired teacher living because she could afford nothing else. ethel couldn't ignore the clear need for health and financial security. and it inspired her to found aarp. for over 50 years, we've continued that work,
10:18 pm
to help all americans pursue their best life. discover more of what we do, for every generation at aarp.org.
10:19 pm
10:20 pm
welcome back to "the ed show." thanks for watching tonight. if the question is can america produce safe, nuclear energy to prevent the kind of crisis we're seeing in japan, well then the answer is not so comforting this evening. there are 104 nuclear plants in the united states and like japan some of those plants are highly vulnerable to earthquakes. the two diablo canyon plants are built on fault lines outside santa barbara. another plant sits on a fault line outside san clemente. despite this the american medical association released a study in january that said the nation remains poorly prepared to respond adequately to a major radiation emergency incident. for some measures, as many as 85% of responding states reported insufficient capability to respond to a radiation incident. that's not good. but the nuclear power industry is still lobbying to relicense these old reactors. 25% of them are leaking or have
10:21 pm
leaked radioactive waste. the nuclear regulatory commission gave more than half of these reactors new, brand new, 25-year licenses. and if you're wondering where the bipartisanship in washington is, look no further than nukes. house republican leader eric canter reaffirmed a commitment to nuclear power this week. president obama outlined a nuclear energy strategy in his state of the union address and in his budget proposal. and not long ago he said, we should model our nuclear safety measures on japan. >> there is no reason why technologically we can't employ nuclear energy in a safe and effective way. japan does it and france does it. >> but nobody expects an earthquake. joining us tonight is the contributing editor of "the nation" magazine and author of "tropic of chaos, climate change and the new geography of
10:22 pm
violence." good to have you on tonight. >> thanks for having me. >> i think americans, myself, wondering about the integrity of the structures that are out there in this country. your thoughts on that? they are old. >> they're old and they're rickety and radiation embrittles metal and most of the crucial components in nuke plants are made of metal. one of the clone plants, there are 23 basically clone reactors similar to the ones that we have melting down or have melting down in japan now, one of the 23 that we have that are exactly the same as vermont yankee, another one is oyster creek outside new york city where we are tonight. both of those are leaking basically due to the embrittlement of metal pipes. the manager of those plants are unable to find where those leaks are yet both of them are up for renewal. i'm not sure if oyster may have been renewed already but vermont yankee has been approved for
10:23 pm
renewal. so the management and regulation of our atomic fleet is, i think, totally inadequate. they overlook all of the obvious problems. most of these plants are essentially 40 years old. the nrc is not only relicensing them to run for another 20 years beyond the 40 years that they were designed to operate but many of them have been given what are called power uprates so are now allowed to run at 120% of their designed and intended capacity. you wouldn't do that to a car or anything else but they're doing it to atomic power plants. >> and how would we upgrade these facilities? how big a lift would this be for our country? how big of an investment and the logistics of it engineeringwise can it be done or would we have to start over? >> well, i don't -- i mean, you could definitely manage these plants more efficiently and more rigorously than they are currently handled and that would be a matter of the nrc
10:24 pm
essentially pressuring the industry to do what it should do, which is, you know, do routine maintenance and replace parts that have broken and all that. but if you tried to build one of these plants now you wouldn't have the right to do it. i mean, because they're like completely outdated. it would be like trying to bring a 1972 toyota online today, just like you would not sell that car. but they want to extend these things for another 20 years and run them at 120% intended capacity. >> the president has been advocating new nuclear plants. is that a proper solution to all of this? >> the new nuke thing is a kenard. it's a pie in the sky. the fact of the matter is until the u.s. government is going to socialize the costs of nuke plants 100%, private capital is not going to really get involved. so alt stuff you hear from lamar alexander and nfrom california
10:25 pm
about how they want a hundred new plants that is smoke and mirrors because wall street does not like nuclear power plants because they always go over cost, are dangerous and expensive but what is really going on is this push to relicense this fleet of 103 existing reactors -- 104. and that's what is going on is pushing these things out way beyond their intended life span and way beyond their intended capacity. >> and looking at our map there, there's a half dozen of them on the west coast that could be very susceptible to earthquakes. >> yeah. >> how dangerous is that? >> it's pretty dangerous. it's very dangerous. from the beginning people were complaining about that. you'll recall the movie "china syndrome" is set in california, right? and 12 days after that movie came out, which is just some corny, you know, hollywood
10:26 pm
thing, three mile island went off. so, yeah. from the beginning people were saying, wait a minute. why are you building atomic power plants on the san andreas fault line? those fault lines are still active. i mean, there is no reason to think that there couldn't be a similar earthquake in california. >> and those are old structures. >> yes. they're old structures. >> yeah. >> radiation makes metal brittle and those are embrittled and it's very dangerous. >> thanks for your time tonight. very insightful. appreciate it very much. >> thank you. the story that can best be told with pictures at the end of this hour tonight. but next, the jabber mouths who continue to mock the victims. glenn beck, rush limbaugh, right up their alley. they're in the takedown. stay with us. ♪ phone surprised you?
10:27 pm
...in a good way. in a jaw to the floor netflix-streaming, office deadline-obliterating, work-ninjaing, xbox live on my phone booootakasha kind of way. you won't believe what windows phone can do... and what your old phone can't. get the only phone with office, xbox live and thousands of apps.
10:28 pm
get a windows phone for $99.99 at at&t. you've been stuck in the garage, while my sneezing and my itchy eyes took refuge from the dust in here and the pollen outside. but with 24-hour zyrtec®, i get prescription strength relief from my worst allergy symptoms. it's the brand allergists recommend most. ♪ lily and i are back on the road again. where we belong. with zyrtec®, i can love the air®. where we belong. across the country when the economy tumbled, jpmorgan chase set up new offices to work one-on-one with homeowners. since 2009, we've helped over 250,000 americans keep their homes. and we're reaching out to small businesses too, lending them more than $10 billion last year.
10:29 pm
we're also giving businesses the opportunity to ask for a second review if they feel their loan should have been approved. this is how recoveries happen. everyone doing their part. this is the way forward. you get nothing for driving safely. truth: at allstate, you get a check in the mail twice a year, every year you don't have an accident. the safe driving bonus check. dollar for dollar, nobody protects you like allstate.
10:30 pm
dollar for dollar, sheet or bar? how do you get your bounce? oh, i'm a forgetter. i tend to forget things all the time. so, i'm a bar person. i don't need to remember the dryer sheet, so if i forget, i'm still good. woman: (shouting) remember the bar! welcome back. we have breaking news at this moment out of japan. a spokesman for the japanese news agency is saying that workers at the number four reactor due to high levels of radiation are being evacuated and are unable to continue to work. this is a major turning point. what does this mean? the people that we were talking about just moments ago on this
10:31 pm
program in there working frantically to control the reactor are now being evacuated due to radiation. what can you deduct from all of that? well, for some of these reactors, they are talking about using fire hoses to spray water into the spent fuel pools. they have to operate these pumps. some of these things might operate for a little bit of time on their own. but with four reactors down and the need to pump cooling water, even the things that seem to be sort of under control, like the reactor vessel in number one, risk getting out of control. as i was explaining, these are pressure cookers and if you don't vent the steam, periodically, then the pressure cookers will explode. buildings -- external buildings -- reactor buildings are already gone, so it's a pretty grave situation. i don't -- i'm not aware of how -- whether they can operate
10:32 pm
these valves automatically and whether the control settings are good enough for them to do that but from what -- the way the accident has unfolded it's very confusing of course for everyone but it doesn't seem that controlled to the extent it exists could last for very long if it is abandoned if it's abandoned and it is out of control, what kind of explosion would we be looking at? >> well, as i said, the reactors themselves are like pressure cookers and the steam will build up. it's got a lot of heat and the reactors would explode and you'd have a massive release of radioactivity because they would lose containment. the buildings are already gone with the hydrogen explosion. the additional radioactivity in the spent fuel pools, and that could also be released and in the worst case, you know, there
10:33 pm
would be so much fallout that the evacuated areas and somewhat beyond could become uninhabitable for quite a bit of time. this is sort of a chernobyl type of scenario and in chernobyl about 400 square miles remain uninhabitable 25 years later. and food had to be dumped hundreds and hundreds of miles away. not for a long time but in germany and scandinavia they had to collect the radioactive food. there was significant fallout, enough to affect food. not enough to make people physically sick that far away but enough for contamination to affect the lives of people hundreds of miles away. >> our guest a nuclear expert tonight. this developing at this hour. japanese news agency reporting that workers at the fukushima nuclear plant are being evacuated because they are unable to work due to the radiation levels and the risks
10:34 pm
they are put at. this would, as i understand, leave the facility unmanned and as you mentioned, possibly some remote capability to keep it under control but there have been numerous explosions. we don't know the capability of the plant. this could take the story to a whole new level. it could bring radiation levels as you said the word "massive." what does that mean? >> well, i don't understand why they're not rotating workers. i mean, maybe the radiation levels are such as to make workers sick in the short term because at certain radiation levels, it's not a long term cancer risk. it's skin burns and the radiation sort of burns the water off your cells and your skin starts peeling and you have a very, very terrible vomiting and sickness and so i can only surmise that people are abandoning or asked to abandon
10:35 pm
their position because they can no longer work. normally they should be able to rotate workers but if it is that radioactive they may not be able to bring new workers in for them to be able to do anything. >> so that would be the next question, would it not? when would they bring workers back in to the facility to try to contain this or is this it? is it on its own, correct? >> well, the short lived radioactivity that would make an intensely radioactive could last for days. and at that time it may be possible for properly suited workers to go back in but what there would be to manage at that stage is very difficult to say. there may be just pieces and very radioactive pieces. that was, you know, the chernobyl reactor i should say was very different. the mechanisms of explosion and the fire were very different. but the end results in terms of the highly radioactive materials that were dispersed could be
10:36 pm
quite similar, although the chemicals would be different and so on. when you have that kind of a radioactive environment very, very difficult for workers to tolerate the radiation. >> what risk now is posed to the people of japan on a grander scale and the people of the world for that matter? >> well, i think the people of japan are -- a lot will depend on the immediate meteorology and how long these releases last. if we take chernobyl as our point of reference, one of the big difficulties of that accident was that the fire lasted for ten days and so the release of the radioactivity lasted for ten days. now, the winds shift a lot over a ten-day period. so it was dispersed in a lot of different directions. there were predominant directions toward the west but it did disperse fairly widely
10:37 pm
across the 360 degrees. now, if these releases are short and it doesn't look like it's headed in that direction, then maybe they would blow out to the ocean. but otherwise the winds do shift and quite a lot of people in japan would be affected. it's very densely populated and as i was saying earlier, some elevated radiation levels can reach for hundreds of miles and in chernobyl there was some global fallout. although it didn't affect us very much here in this country i have to say aquatic life obviously would be affected as well if it goes out to sea. that's not good either way it goes. but developments at this hour, new developments, japanese officials are saying that workers are unable to continue to work at the fukushima nuclear facility and they have been evacuated. and so because of the radiation and due to the radiation the risk that is there. we don't know if they're going to be going back in or another
10:38 pm
crew going back in but this is a big development this hour. thank you so much for joining us tonight on this again. appreciate it. >> well, i'm sorry to have participated in this very horrible news but i'm happy to have been able to help. >> thank you. we rely on your expertise. nothing captures this japan disaster more accurately and urgently than the images that we've been seeing day after day. that's at the end of this hour. but an urgent battle in this country cannot be ignored either. governor john kasich of ohio versus the middle class wage earners. that is next. stay with us. we're america's natural gas.
10:39 pm
and here's what we did today: we put almost three million americans to work... ...adding nearly 400 billion dollars to the economy. generated over two and a half million kilowatts of electricity... ...enough energy to power a quarter of america. we gave your kids a cleaner ride to school. kept the lights on during a calm day at the wind farm. heated 57 million u.s. homes. simmered grandma's chicken noodle soup. melted tons of recycled glass. roasted millions of coffee beans. provided electricity for nearly 29 million home computers. heated your bathwater. cooked your takeout. lit your way home. we helped america import less of its energy. cleared the air by burning cleaner than other fuel sources, with less pollutants and no mercury. and tomorrow, we could do even more. we're cleaner, domestic, abundant and ready now. we're america's natural gas. the smarter power today.
10:40 pm
learn more at anga.us. [ thunder rumbles ] [ male announcer ] the future of mobile computing starts now. the new motorola xoom. powered by the latest android technology, with lightning-fast performance, uncompromising web access and eye-opening hd for the total entertainment experience -- it's everything the tablet should be.
10:41 pm
breaking news at this hour here on "the ed show" tonight. we are getting word from japan that workers at the fukushima nuclear plant have been evacuated. this is a very ominous development. the workers that were trying to control the radiation but due to the radiation risks they have been evacuated and there is no word as to whether more workers
10:42 pm
are going to be going back into that facility to try to control things. we were going to talk about ohio, the budget, and the things that middle class workers are facing but we're going to shift now to ohio congressman dennis kucinich who was going to join us on that issue tonight but, congressman, because of the situation in japan, and also the story we ran earlier tonight documenting that the nuclear facilities in this country, not only old but structurally they have some integrity issues and yet the permitting and licensing just continues. you were the ranking democrat on the nuclear regulatory commission in congress i believe, are you not, congressman? >> that's right, ed. the oversight subcommittee. >> yes. >> of government reform and oversight and it has jurisdiction over the nrc, our subcommittee. >> congressman, where are we at this hour in your opinion as we re-evaluate as a country where
10:43 pm
we are not so much where we're going but the facilities that we have right now and the licensing that's taking place. are you concerned about it? >> i am. because of that, ed, you know, you're going to hear it first here on "the ed show." i'll be sending a letter tomorrow in my capacity as ranking democrat on the oversight subcommittee that has jurisdiction over the nrc, a letter to the nrc asking them to come to capitol hill and give us a full briefing on the full scope of these issues that are being raised in japan as it relates to nuclear reactors in the united states. in particular, i say in the letter to the nrc that any plant operator that has had any difficulty because of let's say dishonesty in their handling of a plant that they should not have their license renewed. they should be shut down. we cannot put the public at risk anywhere in america and i cite in particular a plant in ohio,
10:44 pm
which you may remember in 2002 was discovered to have a hole in the head of the reactor. it was covered up by first energy and it presented a -- the possibility of a catastrophe that could have been close to a level of three mile island. so we have to make sure that all the bad actors in the industry are sorted out very quickly and all these other plants that are up for relicensing, there's going to have to be a very close inspection and examination that is probably unprecedented in the history of the industry. >> congressman, is it easy to get these facilities relicensed? are you satisfied with the oversight when it comes to the relicensing of this -- of these facilities in america where there are documented leaks, consistent leaking? what do you think? >> well, generally relicensing is a perfunctory thing. you have so many, as the doctor pointed out, there are so many of these nuclear facilities that
10:45 pm
are past the stage, operating past the stage at which they're intended to operate. >> life expectancy. >> right. and as has been pointed out the longer these machines, these plants are operating, they're more prone to break down except when you're talking about breakdowns with respect to nuclear power plants the consequences are quite severe. so the plants were not meant to last more than 40 years. and so the nuclear industry trying to wring every last dime of profit out of these plants, you can understand from their perspective, but from a public policy perspective there are safety issues that have to be raised and that's why i'm asking the nrc to come to capitol hill and to give congress a full briefing so that members will have the opportunity to ask the nrc detailed questions on plants across this country and also in my letter i talk about the mark one reactors which are ge
10:46 pm
designed and there are some questions that have been raised about mark one with respect to the events in tokyo. or rather in japan. >> congressman kucinich here on "the ed show" tonight. would you advocate based on what you know shutting down any of these facilities in america? >> well, i've consistently advocated shutting down the nuclear power plant in ohio. >> okay. >> it is no secret that the perry nuclear plant is built -- was built in an earthquake area. they had a 5.0 earthquake a couple decades ago there. >> has the nrc been honest brokers in all of this? >> i think the nrc is going to have to step up right now. what happened in japan changes everything. and it's going to require the nrc to look at nuclear safety through the prism of what happened in japan. now some people say, well, they had an earthquake and a tsunami. look, we have two nuclear power plants in ohio on lake erie which is part of a chain of lakes that is the largest supplier of fresh water in the
10:47 pm
world. could you imagine if we had an event there that would cause a compromise of any of those reactor vessels? we have to be concerned now with public safety and look at what happened in japan as a cautionary tale and so that's why i'm asking the nrc to come forward. >> okay. >> and it's time that they laid out all the cards on the table for congress and answered all of our questions. it is a whole new day and we have to be very concerned about the people in japan. my heart goes out to them. this is a -- what a difficult, difficult series of circumstances. >> it is very difficult. and this country is facing some difficult situations as well. but, congressman, i want to ask you one more thing. former governor bill richardson said on msnbc earlier today that this country is not prepared. the states aren't prepared. and the federal government may not be prepared. and with budget cuts taking place, how concerned are you? if something like this were to happen in america that we don't have a readiness? >> bill richardson would be in a position to know. i think we have to be concerned about readiness.
10:48 pm
this is going to cause a reappraisal of things like evacuation plans in states where they have nuclear reactors in very populated areas. >> so the budget cuts is what i'm focusing on. the budget cuts really are -- should be a priority list. we should not be cutting the preparedness if we could be facing something like that. >> of course we shouldn't be cutting preparedness, ed. you know what those budget cuts are about. it's not because of the deficit. they're cutting the budget in some areas so they can give tax dollars to their friends in other areas. >> congressman, thanks for joining us tonight. i appreciate your time. congressman dennis kucinich of ohio. the breaking news with japan's nuclear power plants, that continues here on the ed show. stay with us. ♪ crossing borders with ease ♪ ♪ clearing customs' a breeze ♪ ♪ that's logistics ♪
10:49 pm
♪ a-di-os, cheerio, au revoir ♪ ♪ off it goes, that's logistics ♪ ♪ over seas, over land, on the web, on demand ♪ ♪ that's logistics ♪ ♪ operations worldwide, ups on your side ♪ ♪ that's logistics ♪ castrol syntec has been reformulated for better performance under the hood. so we gave it a new name. castrol edge with syntec power technology. new name. better formula. it's more than just oil. it's liquid engineering.
10:50 pm
>> it brings your best minds and their brightest ideas together. it helps the largest of companies seize opportunity like the smallest of startups. it's the network-- the intelligent, secure cisco network that lets your employees, partners, suppliers and customers innovate and share so you can unleash the power of your most valuable asset: your people. [ male announcer ] you are a business pro. lord of the carry-on. sovereign of the security line.
10:51 pm
you never take an upgrade for granted. and you rent from national. because only national lets you choose any car in the aisle. and go. you can even take a full-size or above. and still pay the mid-size price. i deserve this. [ male announcer ] you do, business pro. you do. go national. go like a pro. this is your lucky day. pantene's 2-in-1's are customized, with 5 new versions. find yours and love it or twice your money back. that's the smart beauty guarantee. 2-in-1's from pantene. healthy makes it happen. breaking news at this hour. japan has suspended operations to prevent a nuclear power plant from melting down after a surge in radiation made it too dangerous for workers to remain at the facility. workers are unable to continue
10:52 pm
their efforts at the nuclear facility. a nuclear expert will join us next to tell us what this means as the crisis heightens. [ female announcer ] in the past 10 years these 4 brands took home more allure best of beauty awards than any others. pantene... olay... venus & gillette... and secret. the four most awarded brands. keeping you your most beautiful from head to toe. the four most awarded brands. how can expedia now save me even more on my hotel? well, hotels know they can't fill every room every day.
10:53 pm
like this one. and this one. and oops, my bad. so, they give expedia ginormous discounts with these: unpublished rates. which means i get an even more rockin' hotel, for less. my brain didn't even break a sweat. where you book matters. expedia. and here's what we did today in homes all across america: we created the electricity that powered the alarm clocks and brewed the coffee. we heated the bathwater and gave kelly a cleaner ride to school. cooked the cube steaks and steamed the veggies. entertained dad, and mom, and a neighbor or two. kept watch on the house when they slept. and tomorrow we could do even more. we're cleaner, domestic, abundant and ready now. we're america's natural gas. the smarter power today. learn more at anga.us. i want to fix up old houses. ♪ [ woman ] when i grow up, i want to take him on his first flight. i want to run a marathon.
10:54 pm
i'm going to work with kids. i'm going to own my own restaurant. when i grow up, i'm going to start a band. [ female announcer ] at aarp we believe you're never done growing. thanks, mom. i just want to get my car back. [ female announcer ] together we can discover the best of what's next at aarp.org.
10:55 pm
breaking news here tonight on msnbc. at the fukushima nuclear plant, all of the workers have been evacuated within the last hour due to high levels of radiation. this is a rather ominous development and it certainly changes the dynamic of the story
10:56 pm
and a reminder to our viewers coming up after this program msnbc's chris jansing will be anchoring from tokyo and will have the very on-the-ground, latest details on this. again, the workers at the fukushima nuclear plant have been evacuated within the last hour due to radiation levels too high and conditions too severe for them to work in. what this means, we really don't know. for more on all of that let's bring back our guest, the president of the institute for energy and environmental research. on the surface, what does this report mean, that they have evacuated when they have been frantically attempting all day long to cool the rods and control the situation? >> well, the fact that they're not sending in a second crew doesn't mean -- means that it's not just that the crew is exhausted or there is a level of radiation that they received over a long period of time and they can send in another crew. it appears to be that the level
10:57 pm
of the radiation must be so intolerable that even work for a brief time has become very dangerous. so, you know, for a brief while this kind of emergency may operate automatically in terms of injecting water and so on, the pumps can be left on but it can't last for very long. a lot of the equipment in this plant is damaged and, you know, this is a really fog of a giant nuclear accident and it's very hard for me to tell what's going on but it would appear to be headed in a direction of a very major radiological catastrophe. >> japanese officials are not saying whether more workers are going to be going into that environment in the near future or ever for that matter. that announcement was not made. but if there -- if it is unmanned and something were to happen at a higher level, you told us earlier that there could be a massive release of
10:58 pm
radiation which could affect possibly -- how much of an area do you think? well, you know, at this stage we're moving past the levels of the accident and toward the worst case accident for which the reference point so far has been chernobyl. i mean, we don't know the exact inventories of radioactivity in these reactors but together these four reactors have much more electrical generating capacity than chernobyl plus we've got the spent fuel pools with the highly radioactive waste so the inventories of radioactivity are larger than chernobyl. chernobyl of course was a very different fire where the fire was inside the reactor and was propagating a huge amount of radioactivity. and that radioactivity went -- caused food to be dumped hundreds and hundreds of miles away, as far away as poland,
10:59 pm
germany, and scandinavia, and chernobyl of course is in the ukraine, you know, deep in eastern europe or in the former soviet union. and so what i think this appears to be headed to a similar type of catastrophe if no cooling, even a minimal amount of cooling and venting of the steam cannot be maintained. a different mechanism of accident but the release potential appears to be very grave. >> and quickly, finally, the weather plays a big role here if there is a release does it not? >> that's right. so the weather is -- if the release is quick and it blows over the ocean, the japanese people will be very lucky. if the release lasts for a long period of time, then the widespread contamination over populated areas becomes more probable. >> finally, is there a chance that maybe some automatic mechanism was not damaged and they left and they are still in the process of cooling it